Educational content citing HUD 4000.1 and Fannie Mae Selling Guide. Rates, limits and program eligibility verified April 2026 and change frequently. Consult a licensed lender before applying.
CLVFHA

5% Down: FHA vs Conventional

At 5% down, both programmes price competitively for most FICO bands. The verdict turns on FICO tier and hold period. Putting 5% down on FHA does not trigger the 11-year MIP sunset (only 10%+ does), so the structural disadvantage of FHA remains.

Per-FICO breakdown at 5% down on $300k home

FICOFHA annual MIConv PMI rate10-year cost winner
620 to 6390.55%1.10 to 1.50%FHA
640 to 6590.55%0.85 to 1.10%FHA
660 to 6790.55%0.70 to 0.90%Close call
680 to 6990.55%0.55 to 0.70%Conventional
700 to 7190.55%0.45 to 0.60%Conventional
720 to 7390.55%0.35 to 0.50%Conventional
740 to 7590.55%0.30 to 0.40%Conventional
760+0.55%0.20 to 0.30%Conventional

Why 5% down on FHA still gets life-of-loan MIP

Per HUD Mortgagee Letter 2013-04 (still in force), the MIP cancellation rule is binary at 10% down at origination. 5% down lands in the under-10 category and triggers MIP for the full 30-year term. Conventional, by contrast, follows the Homeowners Protection Act (12 USC 4902) which mandates automatic PMI cancellation at 78% LTV regardless of down payment.

PMI cancellation timeline at 5% down conventional

Annual appreciationYear LTV hits 80%Year LTV hits 78%
0% (worst case)Year 17 (amortization alone)Year 19
3% (typical)Year 6 to 7Year 7 to 8
5% (strong)Year 4 to 5Year 5 to 6

You may request PMI removal at 80% LTV with a current appraisal. Automatic cancellation at 78% LTV happens without action under HPA.

Rate disclaimer

PMI rates vary by insurer and lender. Numbers reflect typical mid-2026 rate cards. Consult a licensed loan officer.

Sources

Related: 3% vs 3.5% down | 10% down | MIP vs PMI cost

Updated 2026-04-27