FHA vs Conventional with a 740 Credit Score
740 FICO crosses into the second-best Fannie Mae LLPA band (740 to 759). Conventional PMI is roughly 0.30 to 0.40 percent and cancels in year 8. FHA at this credit profile is the structurally wrong choice for almost every buyer.
Verdict
Conventional, in nearly every scenario. Total savings over a 10-year hold typically exceed $30,000 on a $300k loan once PMI cancellation, the avoided UFMIP, and the LLPA tier advantage are stacked.
Why 740 is the breakpoint
The Fannie Mae LLPA matrix (and the parallel Freddie Mac risk-based pricing grid) defines FICO bands at 760+, 740 to 759, 720 to 739, 700 to 719, 680 to 699, 660 to 679, 640 to 659, and under 640. The price-step from 720-739 to 740-759 is typically 0.25 LLPA points at 95 percent LTV. At 760+ another step lifts the price advantage further. Hitting 740 unlocks the second tier and removes most of the risk premium that makes FHA competitive at lower scores.
$300k home at 740 FICO, 10% down
| Cost line | FHA | Conventional |
|---|---|---|
| Down payment | 3.5% ($10,500) | 10% ($30,000) |
| Base loan amount | $289,500 | $270,000 |
| UFMIP | $5,066 rolled in | None |
| Annual MI | 0.55% | 0.30 to 0.40% |
| MI duration | Life of loan (under 10% down) | Cancels at 78% LTV (~year 6 at 10% down) |
| 30-year MI total | ~$47,520 + UFMIP | ~$6,500 |
The narrow FHA cases at 740 FICO
- FHA 203(k) renovation. If the property needs $25k+ in immediate repairs, FHA 203(k) Standard or Limited may finance them. Conventional HomeStyle is the comparable product; eligibility and rate may favour either depending on borrower and lender. See FHA 203(k).
- Hold under 2 years. Even at 740 FICO, the absolute monthly cost difference is small enough that a buyer planning a job-relocation sale within 2 years may indifferent between the two.
- Manual underwrite for unique income. A 740 FICO buyer with brand-new self-employment or commission income may still hit conventional automated underwriting refusal, and FHA manual underwrite with compensating factors can clear.
Rate disclaimer
Numbers reflect Fannie Mae LLPA Matrix February 2026 and typical PMI provider rate cards. Rates change frequently; consult a licensed loan officer.
Sources
- Fannie Mae LLPA Matrix: LLPA matrix
- HUD ML 2024-04: HUD ML 2024-04
- HPA 12 USC 4902: 12 USC 4902
Related: 700 FICO | 780+ FICO | PMI by FICO